Should it be game over for today’s education system?
It’s outdated. Its purpose has always been to create well-behaved workers for an Industrial Revolution which happened 200 years ago. It’s failing to teach basic skills to every child. It’s trapping students in debt. And it isn’t giving us the skills needed to solve today’s problems. We deserve something better.
I don’t know what school is like today. It’s been a while since I was there. My own schooling is kind of a blur now. But I do remember colours. Mostly shades of grey, some sepia tones, but also that harsh orange light you get in cities at night time. The light you saw in that dodgy underpass 12 seconds before you were robbed.
I see secondary school kids all the time (that’s high school in America). They pretty much look the same, bigger with more hair. Smartphones have replaced Nokia 3310’s, that kind of thing.
I’ve seen the pattern before however. I’ve been through it. And it worries me because I know where it leads.
I did a lot of education. In fact, I did so much that I can’t stop doing it. After 22 years of formal education, I think I’m qualified to talk about it.
It doesn’t work.
Not well enough, anyway. The Western education system is setting us up to fail.
I typed this exact sentence into Google: ‘Why was modern schooling invented?’
This answer popped up immediately:
The modern education system was designed to teach future factory workers to be “punctual, docile, and sober.”
Punctual, I’m alright with that. Docile I’m offended by, and sober… So what if I want to turn up to work drunk. I’m kidding. I never do that, at least not this decade. But these ideas should shock you. I can’t say if this would still be offensive 200 years ago when modern education was designed. Most people had limited literacy and numeracy. Agricultural work was the most common employment route. The Industrial Revolution needed workers with those rudimentary skills.
In defence of Western education at the time, I can see how priming folk for alternative jobs with a basic education may have seemed like a good idea. Ground breaking even. And whatever the experience of factory work in the 1800s, the Industrial Revolution (and slavery) enabled the economic growth that built Britain as we know it.
Fortunately, that’s not the world we live in today. So why are we still putting ourselves, and our children, through the same system?
Consider this framework:
- School lasts 14 years
- Students are divided by age, not by what they need or want to learn, nor by what they’ve already learned
- To succeed, children need to pass exams
- There is little or no opportunity to explore a subject in-depth, to develop a passion, to hone a skill. There’s an hour for one subject, then an hour for another
- Teachers are considered qualified if they have the required education. Whether they love or hate children is irrelevant. While many of us have had great teachers, lots of us have also had a teacher who evidently hated young people and children.
Why become a teacher when you secretly want to slam dunk a 10-year-olds head down a toilet? The logic always baffled me.
Consider these results:
In the last 5 years, 46% of British children got grade 5 (a good pass) or above in English & Maths GCSE. This is the most basic qualification we believe kids need to progress in life. And less than half achieve it.
In 2018, 98,799 children in England (18% of school leavers) left education at 18 without the minimum expected qualifications (5 GCSEs passed or an alternative). These kids have had 14 years of education, costing over £100k. And it hasn't achieved the basics.
Also in 2018, only 75% of year 6 students (10 and 11 year-olds) in England reached the expected standard in their SATs reading test. 25% did not reach it.
It can’t be a coincidence that half the UK prison population is functionally illiterate, meaning they can’t read to the standard of an 11-year-old. Up to 20% of prisoners are completely unable to read. It’s even worse in the US, where up to 75% of prisoners are illiterate. Nobody can navigate today’s world without being able to read.
And it’s all linked back to school. The school to prison pipeline is very real. Over 6 in 10 prisoners have been excluded from school. Don’t even get me started on the stats for Black children.
So school wasn’t designed for today’s world. The reality is it doesn’t even do what it aims to do.
My views on formal education are mixed.